The Immokalee Water & Sewer District has unanimously voted to suspend fluoridation of its community water supply, making it the last area in Collier County to take this step.
The decision was made during the district’s meeting on Jan. 15, where board members cited ongoing concerns and pending guidance from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
“What we have learned is more research is necessary to address the safety and efficacy concerns regarding community water fluoridation,” said Sarah Catala, the executive director of the Immokalee Water & Sewer District.
The court case, Food and Water Watch v. United States EPA , was mentioned throughout public comment, as well as data published in the scientific journal JAMA Pediatrics , which claimed that a double dose of fluoride could create a link between lower IQs and children. The research has prompted the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to conduct further studies to determine safe levels of fluoride exposure due to a 2023 ruling by a California U.S. District Judge.
"This is a blessing for pregnant moms, children, and really, all citizens of Collier County," said Scott Kiley, an advocate with Stand for Health Freedom , who has spoken at meetings in Collier County, Naples, and Immokalee.
Fluoride was removed from Collier County in February of 2024, and Naples via City Council in December of 2024.
“It doesn’t help your teeth, and it harms your body ... This is a forced medical treatment. It is completely unethical, unconstitutional, and against our God-given rights," said Kiley.
Fluoride has been a longtime mineral additive in water supplies across Florida and the United States, used to assist in tooth decay, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The suspension of fluoridation will save the Immokalee Water & Sewer District approximately $8,000 annually.
"The board is contemplating organizations that provide dental care in Immokalee and possibly distributing the money saved to those who provide that service," said Catala.