Just when homeowners along Florida’s Gulf Coast thought the storms were behind them, another blow has arrived — this time by mail.
Residents in parts of Lee County, particularly unincorporated areas of North Fort Myers, are now receiving letters from the county demanding documentation for hurricane repair work. These letters, spurred by Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, are reviving stress for many who believed their homes — and their lives — had finally been restored.
Carol McCarthy, a longtime resident of North Fort Myers, is among those affected. She recalls how close her home came to flooding during Hurricane Ian. “We were just three inches away from water coming into the patio door,” she said, pointing out the high-water mark still visible on her home.
As floodwaters rose, McCarthy’s elevated home became a refuge for her neighbors, many of whom watched helplessly from her second floor as their own houses filled with water. “It was heartbreaking,” she said. “They were standing in my home, watching their own go under.”
In the aftermath, many residents quickly began repairs — some with permits, others without. Now, years later, letters from Lee County are asking for proof, including forms showing the type of work completed, its cost, and whether the proper permits were obtained.
Doug Nellans, of The Insurancenter in Fort Myers, says the sudden scrutiny comes from pressure at the federal level.
“FEMA is making sure homes meet flood compliance standards,” Nellans said. “The county, in turn, is asking homeowners to provide documentation.”
The main issue revolves around FEMA’s “50% Rule.” If the cost of repairs exceeds 50% of a home’s market value, homeowners may be required to make extensive, and expensive, modifications to meet floodplain regulations. These could include elevating the structure, installing flood vents, and using water-resistant building materials.
“The prospect of having to elevate a home is a major construction project,” Nellans said. “It could easily run into tens of thousands of dollars.”
Worse still, some residents are reporting difficulty getting assistance. County offices are overwhelmed, and residents say it's hard to get a human on the phone to answer questions.
“I worry for my friends,” said McCarthy, who is concerned some may be forced to relocate.
Nellans shares that concern. “I wouldn’t be surprised if some people put their homes on the market just to escape the bureaucracy and the costs," he said.
For now, county officials are advising anyone who receives a letter to call the number listed and speak with a representative for guidance.
DOWNLOAD
the free
Gulf Coast News app
for your latest news and alerts on breaking news, weather, sports, entertainment, and more.