Neighbor urges mental health help after Bonita Springs standoff

BONITA SPRINGS, Fla. —

A weekend standoff between a Bonita Springs woman and Lee County deputies is prompting renewed calls from neighbors for increased access to treatment and crisis intervention services.

Ciara Smith remains in custody after an hours-long confrontation with deputies, but those who know her say the situation reflects a mental health crisis rather than criminal intent.

A neighbor who is also a recovery coach said a member of Smith’s family described her behavior as often not making sense, pointing to long-standing mental health struggles.

Joe Scalia only spoke to Gulf Coast News. He said troubling behavior had been evident for months.

“She would come out of the house and just start screaming at nobody, at the air,” Scalia said.

Authorities say the situation escalated Saturday night when Smith exited her home and pointed a handgun at deputies. Deputies reported hearing clicking sounds from the firearm before she retreated back inside.

The Lee County Sheriff’s Office said Smith later appeared in a front window, again pointing the gun toward deputies. Fearing for their safety, a deputy fired a rifle in her direction. No injuries were reported. Smith then barricaded herself inside as deputies repeatedly urged her to come out. Deputies say she eventually exited the home but ignored commands and attempted to run away before being taken into custody.

Scalia said the man Smith lives with feels powerless to get her the help she needs.

“He feels helpless, like there’s nothing he can do for her,” Scalia said.

Investigators say the incident began earlier at Leoni’s Pizza on Bonita Beach Road, where employees called 911 after Smith allegedly entered the restaurant with multiple firearms and handed an employee a note with her name on it.

Neighbor Connie Hill said while the police response drew attention, the situation was troubling to witness.

“You worry about the person that’s going through this,” Hill said.

Scalia said the extensive law enforcement response highlights the need for stronger mental health resources in the community.

“Look at how many resources it took just to de-escalate that situation and end it,” he said. “Jail isn’t always the solution. Getting help is.”

Smith remains in the Lee County Jail, facing three counts of aggravated battery and resisting officers. Neighbors say they hope the case leads to treatment and support rather than punishment alone.

DOWNLOAD the free Gulf Coast News app for your latest news and alerts on breaking news, weather, sports, entertainment, and more on your phone or tablet. And check out the Very Local Gulf Coast app to stream news, entertainment and original programming on your TV.