Marco Island's Tigertail Beach still awaits full recovery post-Ian

MARCO ISLAND, Fla.—Tigertail Beach on Marco Island, a popular spot known for its scenic beauty, is still waiting for a full recovery years after Hurricane Ian. Portions of the beach remain closed, leading one concerned neighbor to reach out to WINK Listens for answers.

Larry Smith, a resident who moved to Marco Island for its beaches, shared his frustrations with WINK News.

"It's been listed in numerous magazines as one of the top ten beaches in the country," said Smith.

When Smith bought his home nine years ago, Tigertail Beach was fully operational, with amenities such as restrooms, concessions, and equipment rentals.

"I could walk right into the park and enjoy all the amenities there," said Smith.

However, after reopening following Hurricane Ian, some facilities never reopened.

"The bathrooms got shut down, and there was a sign on them that said, The bathrooms are unsafe," said Smith. "That was three years ago, and they haven't done anything."

WINK News anchor Amanda Hall took these concerns to county leaders.

"According to county leaders, what's happening here goes far beyond routine repairs, and restoring Tigertail Beach isn't a simple fix," said Hall. "Commissioner Rick LoCastro says the damage to the restrooms is mostly beneath the building."

Moisture and salt have caused corrosion and cracking, making the restrooms unsafe. The repair process is awaiting permits, including a review by the state Department of Environmental Protection. Construction is expected to begin in summer 2027. The restoration involves coastal permitting and FEMA floodplain compliance, which has delayed progress.

The county is also seeking a new vendor to provide food, beverages, chairs, umbrellas, and paddleboard rentals. For Smith, the delay is frustrating.

"This huge benefit is gone. My property taxes have continued to go up every year," said Smith.

Despite the challenges, Smith appreciates the efforts of "WINK Listens" in getting some answers.

"Hopefully we'll get some answers and maybe a little more sense of urgency from Collier County," said Smith.

About a third of the $1.5 million needed for restroom repairs is fully funded, with the rest expected from tourist tax reserves.