Marco Island considers fishing restrictions to protect sea turtles

MARCO ISLAND, Fla. (WINK)—A controversial proposal could soon restrict what beachgoers are allowed to do on the sand at night.

City leaders are considering banning overnight beach fishing during sea turtle nesting season, which begins May 1. The proposed ordinance would prohibit beach fishing from 9 p.m. to 9 a.m. during sea turtle season and require permits for groups of 10 or more people on the beach at night.

"This ordinance, which other municipalities have, have similar language as what we are talking about here is a proactive ordinance, not to be reactive," said Bonita Schwan, a city council member. "We already know we have the most false hatchlings taking place in the whole county, right here in Marco Island."

At the last council meeting on April 20, some city leaders said the ordinance is about protecting sea turtles and responding to concerns about nighttime beach activity. But fishermen say current regulations already address these issues.

Shark fishermen on Marco Island use specialized red lighting designed to protect sea turtles. According to Marco Island police, recent complaints have not resulted in substantiated violations.

"In the last couple months, everything that has been forwarded to FWC has not returned anything as substantiated," a Marco Island police representative said.

The beach and water are considered state-controlled areas. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission regulates fishing activities in these areas.

In a letter to city leaders, FWC raised concerns that the proposed ordinance could conflict with state law and may be unenforceable.

The second hearing is scheduled for next Monday, with a final vote to follow.