Historic Matlacha restaurant and marina to be restored by island realtor

MATLACHA, Fla. (WINK)—A historic restaurant and marina is coming back to life on Matlacha thanks to a business owner on the island.

WINK News Reporter Bella Line got an exclusive walk-through of The Olde Fish House on Matlacha. The property has sat dilapidated for years, but now realtor Char Seuffert and her husband Eric will close on the property Thursday.

“This was our go to place, our date night place," said Carol Scott, Matlacha Civic Association president.

Seuffert said the opportunity came together unexpectedly.

"I was talking to the seller, who's been great to me, and he said, ‘Well, why don't you buy it?’ and that's kind of how this worked out. So it's been a really good win," Seuffert said.

The couple started cleaning out the property last week. Seuffert said the condition of the building made the work difficult.

"A week ago, I don't think you could really walk in there very much. It was absolutely hazardous. There was just piles of dirt and debris," Seuffert said.

Eric told Line they've already gone through 11 dumpsters. The property is located in a historic area of Matlacha, which has brought extra challenges, but Seuffert said they plan to revitalize it back to its iconic state.

"We love the islands with all of our hearts, so the fact that we can have an opportunity to bring this iconic restaurant marina back is just wonderful," Seuffert said.

Seuffert said she wants to hear from the community about their memories of the property.

"We would love to hear any memories and really see some photos, because this is iconic, and we're just we feel very privileged and lucky, and we will definitely honor the history of this property," Seuffert said.

Visitors at the Matlacha Community Park said they're happy to hear about its restoration plans. Todd Bailey said the project fits well with the character of the area.

"It certainly is all about small business, local artists, and that plays in very well with that, and I don't think a chain would necessarily be appropriate for this area," Bailey said.

Thomas Devaney said he appreciates the plan to preserve the property's history.

"I like the idea of keeping everything the same," Devaney said.

Scott said the restoration represents another step in bringing Matlacha back to its former glory.

"We've made a nice comeback, and this is kind of a big stepping stone for the community," Scott said.

Eric Seuffert says it could take years to fully reopen The Olde Fish House and they are starting with fixing up the marina first.