SWFL.io - Local NewsChief WINK Investigates Reporter Chorus Nylander
•7/6/2026
NAPLES, Fla. (WINK) — When the alarm rings, firefighters run toward the chaos that everyone else is desperately trying to escape. Most will praise their physical strength, bravery, and lifesaving heroism. But behind the heavy gear and the stoic uniforms lies a silent, devastating mental health crisis—and data shows that Florida is at the epicenter of this national tragedy.
According to tracking data compiled by the Firefighter Behavioral Health Alliance (FBHA), Florida leads the nation in sheer numbers with 182 recorded firefighter suicides since the organization began gathering data in the early 2000s. When adjusted for population, Florida is just slightly edged behind Illinois.
Alarmingly, experts warn that this number is likely just the tip of the iceberg. Because there is no official, mandatory central reporting system for first responder suicides, the FBHA estimates that only about 60% of these tragic events are ever reported. The tracking includes career, volunteer, wildland, and military personnel, as well as those who have left the service but carried the crushing weight of the trauma home with them.
"This room is kind of like one of the most important rooms in the firehouse," Weinbaum says. "It's where we eat, it's where we kind of have our family time, right? And this is where we solve the world's problems right here at this table." Around that table, crews often use dark humor to begin coping with difficult incidents on a company level.
But solving those problems becomes infinitely harder when the trauma accumulates year after year. The relentless schedule alone takes a heavy physical toll. At Station 21—the busiest house in Greater Naples, running over 500 calls a month—crews rarely sleep through the night.
"You're getting up almost every hour on the hour," Weinbaum says, describing standard shifts that bring two, three, or four emergency calls after midnight. Every single call injects a massive dose of adrenaline into the body—a spike that used to be exacerbated by loud, harsh station bells that research later revealed caused severe heart issues among personnel.
Over time, that adrenaline fades into a map of painful memories. "I can't drive around this town without seeing a scar on a tree, or a gouge in the pavement," Weinbaum shares. "Most people drive by that stuff, and they don't recognize it... but I actually know what that means. So yeah, it follows you home. I've had calls that have kept me up at night—nightmares or whatever."
Early in his career, one particular call pushed Weinbaum to the brink, nearly causing him to walk away from the profession entirely. He chose to stay, channeling that pain into advocacy. But the danger became profoundly personal when one of his own mentors—a man who was actually a prominent advocate for first responder mental health—took his own life.
"That was a shock to so many of us in this area," Weinbaum recalls. "He was the guy that was actually a huge proponent of mental health for firefighters, and then it just... became too much for him."
The sheer volume of trauma first responders witness is radically detached from the average human experience.
According to data from the International Association of Firefighters (IAFF), the average American experiences three traumatic events in their entire lifetime. A professional firefighter, by contrast, experiences an average of nine traumatic events in a single year of service. Over a 25-to-30-year career, that cumulative exposure is staggering.
"The impacts will likely be felt," says Hannah Elmore, Senior Clinical Outreach Coordinator for the IAFF Center of Excellence. "Whether it's felt in one's marriage, felt in one's ability to sleep well, or felt in one's physical health." Elmore notes that, left unaddressed, this trauma becomes the building block for PTSD, major depressive disorder, anxiety, and substance abuse.
Jeff Dill, the founder and CEO of the FBHA and a retired battalion chief himself, refers to the psychological barrier preventing firefighters from seeking help as "cultural brainwashing."
"When you hear the term firefighter, what words come to your mind? Hero, brave, courageous," Dill explains. "Now imagine putting this uniform on, and we have that [mindset]: 'I have to be strong, brave, heroic, courageous, show no weakness. I don't ask for help. I handle everything on my own.' And then, when you are challenged in your personal life... it becomes very challenging, because we don't want to show any weakness."
Dill highlights that FBHA data points to moral injury—an emotional wound based on broken relationships and systemic or personal conflict—as an even larger driver of suicide than fear-based post-traumatic stress. "Relationships are the number one known reason why we are killing ourselves," Dill says.
Furthermore, these behavioral health challenges don't always manifest as suicide; they frequently surface as alcoholism, marital issues, or reckless, adrenaline-seeking behavior meant to counteract a profound sense of emotional numbness.
Historically, Dill says the fire service environment dictated a "suck it up and push it down" mentality. "Back in the day, you didn't talk about how a call bothered you," Weinbaum says. "If we can't get help immediately, we're going to either stuff it or fix it ourselves. When you have to wait 72 hours for an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) to call you back, that doesn't work."
To bridge this gap, Greater Naples Fire Rescue Wellness Coordinator and Chaplain David Wilsman has been collaborating with Weinbaum for the last two years to build a comprehensive behavioral health access plan. Recognizing that mental health care is not a "one size fits all" issue, they are studying successful models from other Florida agencies, such as Coral Springs and Marion County.
The program re-engineers how help is requested and delivered:
Immediate Digital Access: Developing a streamlined smartphone interface where a struggling firefighter can bypass waitlists and get immediate help at the press of a button.
Automatic De-escalation: Instead of asking a crew "Are you good?" after a severe call—a question most are programmed to answer with a default "yes"—the department is implementing automatic Critical Incident Stress Debriefings (CISM). Crews are automatically taken out of service to talk.
Vetted, Culturally Competent Clinicians: Partnering with therapists who understand first responder culture so personnel don't waste precious session time explaining shift work or terminology.
Retiree Inclusion: Extending these resources to retired veterans who lose their sense of identity and firehouse support system after hanging up their boots.
"There really isn't an excuse anymore for anybody to say, 'I wasn't offered help,' or 'I didn't have help at the push of a button,'" Wildman says.
Though Florida leads the nation in total numbers, both Dill and Elmore credit the state’s high statistics in part to its proactivity. Organizations like the Florida Professional Association of Firefighters (FPF) actively fund travel assistance and behavioral health training, meaning Florida personnel are much more likely to actively step forward and report their struggles.
Yet, the battle is far from won. Dill argues that fewer than 10% of fire and EMS organizations nationwide have formal, comprehensive behavioral health policies in place. He advocates for mandatory annual behavioral health checkups alongside standard physicals.
"We would have no problem going to a doctor if we blew out a knee on the scene," Dill states. "Now we've maybe seen five children killed in a house fire. Why would we not be scarred that way as well?"
As Chief Weinbaum prepares for retirement, his focus remains entirely on the family he leaves behind at Station 21.
"I love working with the men and women of this fire department," Weinbaum says. "My bucket is full... [but] when I walk out these doors, I hope this program that myself and the chaplain have worked on makes it so we don't lose a single firefighter again."
Seeking Help: If you or a first responder you know is struggling with mental health, PTSD, or thoughts of self-harm, please break the silence. You can call or text the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988, or reach out directly to the Firefighter Behavioral Health Alliance at gffbha.org or the IAFF Center of Excellence for specialized first responder resources.
If you have a story you’d like WINK Investigates to look into, email us at winkinvestigates@winknews.com or call our tip line at 239-344-5074.